Butyrate has so many benefits, combatting autoimmunity, cancer, and psychological disorders. It also changes the epigenetics in our brain.
Sodium butyrate protected newborn pigs intestines. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmicb.2018.01652/full
Where Do We Get Butyrate From?
|Proportion of SCFA energy (kJ) produced|
|Carbohydrate||Butyric Acid||Propionic Acid||Acetic Acid|
Aside from being produced by bacterial fermentation, butyrate can also be produced in much lower concentrations by mammalian cells through fatty acid oxidation and glucose metabolism [13,14] and can be found in plant oils and animal fats . Butyric acid (the acid form of butyrate) is also present in the milk of ruminant animals, such as cows. Butter contains 3–4% butyric acid, in the form of tributyrin (butyryl triglyceride), making it the richest dietary source of butyrate . Interestingly, the term butyrate originates from the Greek word for butter [16,17]. One molecule of tributyrin is metabolized into three butyrate molecules by intestinal enzymes. Tributyrin (1 g/kg) was able to elevate portal vein concentrations of butyrate to 2.4 mM after 1 hour in rats .
Resistant starch is found naturally in many common foods, including grains, vegetables, beans, seeds, and some nuts, but in small quantities, just a few percent of the total. As I discuss in my video Getting Starch to Take the Path of Most Resistance, there are a few ways, though, to get some of the rest of the starch to join the resistance.
When regular starches are cooked and then cooled, some of the starch recrystallizes into resistant starch. For this reason, pasta salad can be healthier than hot pasta and potato salad can be healthier than a baked potato, but the effect isn’t huge. The resistant starch goes from about 3 percent up to 4 percent. The best source of resistant starch is not from eating cold starches, but from eating beans, which start at 4 or 5 percent and go up from there.
If you mix cooked black beans with a “fresh fecal” sample, there’s so much fiber and resistant starch in the beans that the pH drops as good bacteria churn out beneficial short-chain fatty acids, which are associated both directly and indirectly with lower colon cancer risk.
- Resistant starch is a type of starch that’s “resistant” to digestion — your body can’t break it down. Once resistant starch arrives in the colon intact, good bacteria feeds on it, producing beneficial short-chain fatty acids.
- Resistant starch carries many benefits: it strengthens the gut, burns fat, and protects against colon cancer, diabetes, and heart disease.
- The best sources of resistant starch are green banana and plantain flours, cooked and cooled white rice, and raw potato starch.
Other sources: https://selfhacked.com/blog/butyrate-health-benefits/
Health Benefits of Butyrate
- Crucial For Gut Health
- Increases Gene Activity
- Fights Inflammation
- Good for the Brain and Nerve Cells
- Used for Treating Anxiety, Depression, and Mania
- Both a Cure and an Enemy in Case of Addictions
- Has Anti-Cancer Properties – Colon Cancer
- Can Help With Weight Loss
- May Be Good For Balancing Blood Sugar
- Can Help Treat Allergies
- May Help Autism
- Can Be Useful In Alzheimer’s and Huntington’s
- Good For The Mitochondria
- Protects the Liver, Pancreas, and Heart
- May Increase Red Blood Cells
- Can Kill Certain Bacteria Directly
- May Increase Dopamine
Cautions and Side Effects of Butyrate
Increasing Butyrate Levels
Butyrate in green bananas and rice
Butyrate has so many benefits, combatting autoimmunity, cancer, and psychological disorders. It also changes the epigenetics in our brain (R).
- Is a major energy source for colon cells
- Has anti-cancer effects
- Increases mitochondrial activity
- Prevents toxins from crossing gut barrier
- Prevents activation of intestinal glucose production
- Improves insulin sensitivity
- Increases energy expenditure by improving mitochondrial function, reducing obesity
- Increases intestinal barrier function – an anti-inflammatory potential
- Protects against diet-induced obesity without necessarily causing a reduction in caloric intake (mediated through gut hormones).
- Increases the synthesis of leptin (which reduces appetite)
Where Do We Get Butyrate From?
Butyrate is a molecule that is called a short-chain fatty acid.
Fatty acids are building blocks of fats and our cells can not be without them. This particular fatty acid is very small and is usually is made by bacteria living in our gut mostly from fibers derived from grains, beans, onions and bananas.
Butyrate production is determined by the level of bacteria that produce butyrate, and the pH of the large intestine.
Butyrate-producing bacteria seem to thrive in a more acidic environment (lower pH), whereas acetate and propionate bacteria seem to thrive in a more alkaline environment (higher pH) (R).
Butyrate is mainly produced by Firmicutes (R).
Butyrate can also be made by animals’ own cells – for example, it can be found in the form of butyric acid in dairy products (especially butter) [R4].
Plant oils also contain butyrate to some extent [R4].
Therefore, people receive butyrate mostly from their diet.
According to research, not all plant-based foods yield butyrate equally: for example, diets rich in fruit or in starch increases butyrate content in rats [R7, R8], but starch free wheat bran doesn’t [R8].
Studies have shown that eating more fiber increases butyrate production [R].
There is a positive association between a higher intake of plant foods and increased levels of short-chain fatty acids in stools.
Short Chain Fatty Acids provide about 10% of our daily calorie needs [R].
- Inulin: Food sources include artichokes, garlic, leeks, onions, and asparagus.
- Fructooligosaccharides (FOS): Food sources include fruits and vegetables, including bananas, onions, garlic and asparagus.
- Resistant starch (Hi-Maize): Food sources include green bananas and rice that has been cooked and then cooled.
- Pectin: Food sources include apples, apricots, carrots, oranges and others.
- Guar gum
- Arabinogalactan (R)
Health Benefits of Butyrate
1) Butyrate Is Crucial For Gut Health
Butyrate is important for creating tolerance in the gut and promoting an anti-inflammatory environment.
Butyrate is mostly not absorbed because it is primarily used by colon cells, where is serves as a major source of energy for them (R).
Butyrate-producing bacteria (such as Clostridium butyricum) live in the end part of the gut, in the colon [R9].
Colon cells prefer butyrate for sustenance [R10].
In the mitochondria of colon cells, 70% to 90% of butyrate is oxidized into acetyl-CoA, which is subsequently processed through the tricarboxylic acid cycle to generate a large quantity of ATP (R).
Butyrate and its “production factories” are imperative for intestinal health [R15].
Colorectal cancer [R14],
Diarrhea – resistant starch has been shown to reduce diarrhea in children [R,R2]. Butyrate in combination with several other substances was also shown to be beneficial for the treatment of traveler’s diarrhea – a condition common among tourists, especially those who travel to exotic countries [R60].
Butyrate supplements resulted in improvements in 53% of Crohn’s disease patients[R].
An enema of short-chain fatty acids, twice per day for 6 weeks, helped reduce symptoms of Ulcerative Colitis by 13% [R].
There is a variety of approaches for using butyrate for the treatment of inflammatory bowel disease and colitis. The treatment strategies range from high-fiber diet, butyrate-producing bacteria, coated tablets and rectal enemas [R58, R59].
Bacteria that produce butyrate can only live in oxygen-free conditions, so this approach is difficult to apply [R59].
2) Butyrate Increases Gene Activity
Butyrate is able to influence which genes are active.
There are several mechanisms in the cell that control gene activity by changing composition of the chromosome proteins (or histones).
An addition of a methyl group to a part of the histone (methylation) forces it to cling tightly to the gene nearby, successfully blocking its production.
Another reaction called acetylation (addition of an acetyl group) frees an area of DNA and increases gene production.
Butyrate helps maintain “open” and productive state of genes by blocking a protein that takes off acetyl groups [R16].
This activity turns out to be extremely important in many different conditions.
3) Butyrate Fights Inflammation
Many researchers show that butyrate can influence the activity of immune system. It was observed rather early that addition of butyrate to the culture of immune cells has a double-edged effect [R17].
On one hand, butyrate blocks the development of new immune cells participating in inflammation. On the other hand, it stimulates the production of some inflammatory proteins [R17].
Later research also performed on cell cultures has proven that butyrate does reduce inflammation. Butyrate suppresses the activity of cells and proteins driving inflammation [R18].
Butyrate is also good for reversing alcohol damage. It was observed that mice given butyrate before being injected with high doses of ethanol had less inflammation and damage to the inner organs compared to controls [R20].
These anti-inflammatory properties may be partly connected to the ability of butyrate to support the development of specific immune cells that block inflammation in the lining of the end gut in mice [R21].
Butyrate also strengthens barriers between the cells, thus preventing invasion of microbes [R22].
4) Butyrate Is Good for the Brain and Nerve Cells
Sodium butyrate, like exercise, places the brain into a state of “readiness for plasticity” and can benefit long-term memory [R].
It was shown on the model of a stroke in mice that treatment of the animals with sodium butyrate after brain injury supports the development of new nerve cells in the damaged areas [R23].
Also, treatment with sodium butyrate in mice that have brain trauma strengthens the barrier between brain and blood, which helps recovery [R24].
Butyrate is useful in with other types of nerve damage as well: for example, sodium butyrate was reported to protect nerve cells in the ear after treatment with antibiotics thus preventing hearing loss [R25].
It is not true for sodium butyrate only, but for other butyrate containing preparations, too. For example, the death of nerve cells obtained from mice with stroke-like injury was prevented by treatment with 3-hydroxy-butyrate (3-OBA) [R26].
The same protective effect was shown for sodium 4-phenylbutyrate (4-PBA), a drug used for a number of genetic disorders [R27]
Cultures of butyrate-producing bacteria can also be used to treat nerve damage.
Mice pretreated with a butyrate-producing bacterial species fared better in a model of brain injury [R28].
These bacteria were also beneficial in a more complicated case of brain injury – in vascular dementia, a disease when nerve cells die progressively due to blood vessel blockages [R29]
Butyrate-producing bacteria are able to improve the quality of the barrier between brain and blood in healthy mice as well [R30].
Sodium butyrate can also prevent the death of nerve cells in the spine in the model of spinal muscular atrophy in mice [R31].
Sodium phenylbutyrate was beneficial for the treatment of a systemic disease caused by nerve cells death – amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). It prevented the death of nerve cells responsible for activating movement [R32].
5-7) Butyrate Is Used for Treating Anxiety, Depression, and Mania
Sodium butyrate and sodium phenylbutyrate are beneficial against depression and other types of mood disorders [R33].
It also had an anti-manic and anti-oxidant effect in rat models of mania [R35].
One possible mechanism of such influence may be due to the fact that sodium butyrate influences the processes in the hippocampus, the part of the brain responsible for emotions and emotional memory (it increases several proteins that support nerve cell development) [R36].
Sodium butyrate alleviates depression and increases cognition ability in mice [R37].
It can also restore memory formation when it is blocked with certain substances [R38].
Sodium butyrate protects from stress in general. It is proposed to prescribe sodium butyrate together with anti-seizure drugs because they are less effective if an afflicted person is under stressful conditions [R39]
Another butyrate-containing drug form, sodium phenylbutyrate, was also shown to be good for improving anxiety and depression in mice [R40].
8) Butyrate Is Both a Cure and an Enemy in Case of Addictions
Butyrate containing drugs are a double-edged sword when treating addiction. In alcohol-addicted rats, supplementation of their diet with sodium butyrate has lessened the quantity of alcohol the animals consumed [R41].
It was also shown that phenylbutyrate can reduce the desire for cocaine in a rat model of cocaine addiction [R42].
On the other hand, there is increasing evidence that butyrate can act in concert with such drugs of abuse as cocaine, helping to establish certain behaviors caused by the addiction [R43].
9) Butyrate Has Anti-Cancer Properties
The possibility of using butyrate for the treatment of cancer was entertained as early as the 1980s. In a clinical trial of sodium butyrate for leukemia treatment it was established that the drug is too easily eliminated from the body to be really effective [R46].
It was also shown experimentally that butyrate is able to destroy cancer cells in cancer cell cultures which may result in:
- cancer cell death [R47, R48];
- the partial self-destruction of the cancerous cells [R49];
- prevention of nourishment for the tumors [R50].
But butyrate is not effective enough on its own, in a whole organism, as mentioned [R46].
So there are several strategies and new drugs employed for fighting cancer.
First of all, there is tributyrin, a novel prodrug that can be found in dairy products. This prodrug was tested in patients with advanced solid tumors and was evaluated as effective [R51].
There are at least two more butyrates – containing preparations with anti-cancer activity that are being potentially tested at present:
- pivanex that was shown to prevent metastases and blood vessel growth in tumors [R52];
- butyroyloxyalkyl, a substance that transforms into formaldehyde in the cell. Formaldehyde is highly poisonous for living cells and can kill cancer cells effectively [R53]
There is another promising strategy – using sodium butyrate together with other substances. For example, administration of sodium butyrate with nicotinamide and calcium glucarate can prevent the formation of skin tumors in mice [R54].
In leukemia cancer cells, a combination of sodium butyrate and artemisinin, a plant-derived anticancer compound, was very effective in killing cancerous cells at low doses [R55].
Some authors proposed to combine IL-2 – a cytokine that activates killer cells – with butyrate [R56].
The suggestion is based on the trials performed on rats that have shown butyrate to be able to make tumor cells into better targets for killer immune cells stimulated by IL-2 [R56].
The last untested approach is to inject butyrate – producing bacteria into the tumors in order to destruct them from within [R57].
Mice on a high-fiber diet and had butyrate-producing bacteria got 75% fewer tumors than the mice who did not have the bacteria [R].
The high-fiber diet without the bacteria to make butyrate did not have protective effects against colon cancer [R].
10) Butyrate Can Help With Weight Loss
It is well established that supplementing resistant starch and dietary fibers in diet, confer metabolic benefits in humans [R65].
In rodent models of genetic or diet-induced obesity, supplementation of butyrate in the diet was shown to suppress weight gain in part by inhibiting caloric intake [R65] and by increasing energy expenditure [R].
11-12) Butyrate May Be Good For Balancing Blood Sugar
Butyrate was also shown to improve various aspects of diabetes.
People with diabetes have an imbalance of gut flora. A review of the evidence reported that butyrate can have positive effects in both animals and humans with type 2 diabetes [R].
In mice, butyrate makes pancreatic cells sensitive to insulin [R63].
It was shown in young diabetic rats that sodium butyrate protects and supports insulin-producing cells and prevents the release of sugar into blood [R64].
13) Butyrate Can Help Treat Allergies
It was shown that sodium butyrate has decreased several parameters characteristic for allergy in mice with allergic rhinitis [R67].
14) Butyrate May Help Autism
It was shown in mice that addition of sodium butyrate improves autistic behavior [R71].
Another study has shown that sodium butyrate helped autistic mice to recognize objects better [R72].
But it is also known that propionic acid, a chemical relative of butyrate (also found in the gut), can be used for creating autism-like behavior in mice and rats [R73].
Such contradicting results indicate that this issue should be researched more extensively.
15-16) Butyrate Can Be Useful In Alzheimer’s and Huntington’s
Those drugs improve memory in afflicted mice by increasing gene activity in relevant brain areas [R75].
Phenylbutyrate also prevents protein accumulation in the brain [R76].
Sodium butyrate was also demonstrated to beneficial in a mouse model of Huntington’s disease [R69].
Huntington’s disease is a condition caused by damage in nerve cells that slowly begin to die out. It was shown that therapy with phenylbutyrate in mice with this condition has improved their movements, body weight, ability to recognize objects and gene production [R69].
The same beneficial effect was shown on the cell culture that carried the faulty gene causing Huntington’s disease in humans, where the addition of sodium butyrate to the culture allowed the cells to live longer [R70].
17) Butyrate is Good For The Mitochondria
It was proposed to use butyrate with lipoic acid for prevention and treatment of radiation injury [R77].
Butyrate can protect cells against radiation because it is good for cells’ “energy factories” – mitochondria, which are often destroyed by radiation [R77].
18-20) Butyrate Protects the Liver, Pancreas, and Heart
Butyrate helped to improve liver disease in animals [R61].
Sodium butyrate was also reported to protect the pancreas from damage [R62].
Sodium butyrate can prevent atherosclerosis [R66].
Butyrate is thought to interact with key genes that make cholesterol, possibly reducing cholesterol production [R].
21) Butyrate May Increase Red Blood Cells
Due to butyrate gene-influencing activity, it can switch on the hemoglobin gene that works during the development of the child in the womb, thus ensuring the appearance of properly working red blood cells [R68].
22) Butyrate Can Kill Certain Bacteria Directly
It was recently found that n-butyric acid can directly kill Salmonella (a bacteria that causes salmonellosis and severe diarrhea) and Clostridia perfringes (causes gangrene) [R78].
Moreover, butyrate can directly influence gene activity in Salmonella, making the bacteria less dangerous and vulnerable to killing [R80].
At present butyrate is used mostly for treating salmonellosis in poultry [R81].
Recently, the researchers discovered that butyrate can destroy the cell wall in Helicobacter pylori – a bacteria causing gastritis [R82].
There are no reports found about direct applications of butyrate against human bacterial infections, except a trial of butyrate treatment against shigellosis carried out on rabbits [R83].
The trial was successful, but it mostly reports the favorable reaction to butyrate intake and health improvement but does not register direct antibacterial effect [R83].
Butyrate can also kill bacteria indirectly by increasing the production of specific antimicrobial proteins that help the organism to destroy bacteria [R84].
This fact is also true for phenylbutyrate [R85].
23) Butyrate May Increase Dopamine
Butyrate increases the enzyme that produces dopamine (tyrosine hydroxylase) (R).
Cautions and Side Effects of Butyrate
Butyrate may drive cancerous cell growth in the gut (in antibiotic-treated mice) [R].
Butyrate may prevent stem cells in the gut from growing and repairing the gut after an injury or autoimmune diseases like inflammatory bowel disease(IBD) [R]. Butyrate inhibits the growth of these cells by increasing the Foxo3 gene, which is associated with IBD [R].
The gut crypts are structured such that the stem cells at the top are protected from butyrate in the gut. However, in conditions where the villi are sufficiently damaged, the stem cell in the gut may not be protected [R].
Increasing Butyrate Levels
Since I take a total of 8 pills a day, I’d rather not have a brand that has excipients.
I also take Modified Citrus Pectin. I actually find that it has a nootropic and wakeful promoting effect for me. It also chelated heavy metals, while leaving your beneficial minerals. So this is a great choice.
Each source of butyrate is good in different ways. Butyrate gets to the stomach and small intestines, whereas the fibers are obviously better at producing butyrate in the large intestine.
- Calcium, Magnesium Butyrate by Body Bio
- Hi-Maize (Honeyville, available in 5-pound bag) [R] – the best option
- Butyrate -Calcium/Magnesium or Butyrate -Calcium/Magnesium or Butyrate -Calcium/Magnesium (no lead warning)
- Modified Citrus Pectin
- Colostridium butyricum [R]
Feb 9, 2018 – Abstract. Butyrate, a four-carbon short-chain fatty acid, is produced through microbial fermentation of dietary fibers in the lower intestinal tract.
Butyrate is a short-chain fatty acid anion that is the conjugate base of butyric acid, obtained by deprotonation of the carboxy group. It has a role as an EC 220.127.116.11 …